Summer Heights High was a critical smash and was successful upon it’s release. So much so, was that Chris Lilley ultimately revisited these characters, but in my opinion, had a different outcome. Why?
Well. Summer Heights High had all of the characters together within the one TV show. They never interacted with one another but that was part of the fun. You got to have an idea of the entire school from these 3 characters, of Jonah the rebellious trouble maker, Mr. G, the dramatic drama teacher and Ja’mie the spoilt private school girl. All 3 of these characters were all situated within the same school, and all of them had their own separate story arcs.
However, when Chris Lilley created seperate TV shows for Ja’mie and Jonah, they lacked the diversity. When you focus you’re whole attention on one character, they must have some sort of variety to keep them fresh and interesting. These characters really lack the diversity to have this, which in saying that makes them humorous, however on their own within a mockumentary style TV show can become repetitive and bland. Again, this is all my opinion, no scientists were involved in calculating this post. Here’s a trailer for Ja’mie:
The reason why the combination works, as opposed to the solo story, is that it gives a contrast in tone. Summer Heights High’s intercutting between 3 different dysfunctional characters created more comedy due to the fact that you’re just seeing the school day differently from different perspectives. It’s the blend of the troubled school boy and the upper classed school girl that creates a more diverse TV show as they’re both disrupting the world around them in different ways. When all the focus is on just the private school girl and her own little world, it began to annoy. When I watched Ja’mie, I wanted to have Mr G change the tone and show the funny world he lives in.
The results speak for themselves, as according to Wikipedia, Ja’mie’s viewership went from 0.92 million viewers in it’s first week to 0.62 million for it’s finale. That’s in contrast to Summer Heights High: it had 1.2 million viewers for it’s first episode and finished with around 1.5 million. This is quite a small analysis, but audiences tend to enjoy variety of characters, as opposed to just those characters.
That’s something that I know would be cool to have within our own mockumentary. Different characters who all have their own silly situations and stories, yet all have one thing in common; Melbourne.
REFERENCES:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/fa/Summerheightsratings.jpg
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ja%27mie:_Private_School_Girl
-youtube videos above…